• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Nevada Business Magazine

The Decision Maker's Magazine

Subscribe Now!

  • Subscriptions
    • Print
    • Mobile App
    • Email
    • Nevada News & PR Wire
  • Features
    • New This Month
    • View Issues
    • Cover Stories
    • Feature Stories
    • Industry Focus
    • Building Nevada
    • Special Reports
    • Meet the Decision Maker
    • Press Release Wire
    • Nevada Industries
  • Departments
    • A Matter of Opinion
    • Around the State
    • Business Indicators
    • Commentary
    • Commercial RE Report
    • Crossfire
    • Expert Advice
    • Face to Face
    • Free Market Watch
    • Inside Politics
    • Power of Attorney
    • Profit & Loss
    • Speaking for Nevada
    • Tech.knowledge.me
    • The Last Word
    • Vital Signs
  • Planning Calendar
  • Advertising
    • Advertising Info
    • Advertising Staff
    • Submission Requirements
    • Online Advertising
  • Events
    • NBM Events
  • About
    • About the Magazine
    • Contact the Staff
  • Connect
    • Business Directory
    • Press Release Wire
    • Business Calendar
    • Submit Listing
    • Post Press Release
    • Add Your Event
    • Sign Up
    • Log In
You are here: Home / Departments / Crossfire / Question 3 Nevada: A Nevada Constitutional Amendment on Energy

Question 3 Nevada: A Nevada Constitutional Amendment on Energy

September 1, 2018 By Nevada Business Mag Leave a Comment

One of the questions on this November’s ballot, Question 3, will address energy in Nevada. A proposed constitutional amendment, the question must be approved in two consecutive election years. Having passed in 2016, this is the second time it’s appeared on the ballot.

The question reads: “Shall Article 1 of the Nevada Constitution be amended to require the Legislature to provide by law for the establishment of an open, competitive retail electric energy market that prohibits the granting of monopolies and exclusive franchises for the generation of electricity?”

Nevada Business Magazine asked both sides to state why they oppose or support Question 3. The responses follow.

Why do you oppose Question 3?

by the Coalition to Defeat Question 3

Question 3 is a constitutional amendment on this November’s statewide ballot that would raise our electricity rates, eliminate consumer protections, and lock a risky experiment into our state constitution. The deeply flawed ballot measure would force Nevada to dismantle its current regulated electricity system – one of the most reliable and affordable in the nation – and replace it with a new, unknown system established by the legislature and the courts.

The reality is we do not know what we are voting on with the extremely vague wording of this ballot measure. The proponents have not provided any details or instructions on how Nevada’s new electricity system would be set up or function.

Because Question 3 contains ambiguous and contradictory language, it would spark significant legal challenges and court battles over its implementation. This uncertainty would slow investments into Nevada’s energy infrastructure, hurting economic development and jeopardizing thousands of good-paying jobs.

Question 3 would also make Nevada the first and only state to deregulate its electricity system through a constitutional amendment, locking this risky experiment into Nevada’s Constitution. When things go wrong, it would take at least four years and multiple legislative sessions to repeal it from our state constitution.

Many states1 – including Nevada in the late 1990s – tried unsuccessfully to deregulate their electricity systems. It resulted in significantly higher electricity prices, less reliable service, rolling blackouts, spikes in customer complaints, and predatory marketing scams that target seniors and consumers on low and fixed incomes.

Question 3 would cost Nevada consumers billions. According to the Public Utilities Commission of Nevada (PUCN)2 dismantling our existing electricity system would cost consumers at least $4 billion. That’s because the state’s major energy provider, NV Energy, would be forced to divest its generating facilities and power plants. Nevada ratepayers would remain liable for any financial losses incurred for these stranded costs.

The PUCN also found that implementation of Question 3 would result in upwards of $100 million in new start-up costs, and more than $45 million in new annual operating and maintenance costs, money that would come directly out of the pockets of residential customers and small businesses in the form of higher electricity rates and higher taxes.

For example, residential customers in southern Nevada could see a monthly increase of up to $28, and some northern Nevada commercial customers facing a nearly $370 per month increase for at least a decade.

Today, Nevada’s average electricity rates are already lower than all 14 deregulated states. In fact, in those deregulated states, average residential electricity rates are 30% higher than Nevada’s.

Question 3 would damage Nevada’s renewable energy sector3 and would eliminate Nevada’s current rooftop solar program.

If passed, Question 3 would eliminate Nevada’s existing rooftop solar program. Both the PUCN and the Guinn Center4 found there are no guarantees that rooftop solar customers would continue to receive favorable net-metering rates for electricity returned to the grid under Question 3.

Question 3 would also cancel an unprecedented plan to double renewable energy production in Nevada by 2023. Question 3 would shut down six new solar projects that would create more than 1,700 construction jobs and generate 1001 megawatts of renewable energy. That’s enough new clean energy to power 600,000 Nevada homes.

There are many reasons why it’s been nearly 20 years since any state has taken the risk of implementing a system like the one Question 3 proposes. We are urging all Nevadans to look carefully into the facts and vote No on Question 3.

Why do you support Question 3?

by Yes on Question 3

Warren Buffett, the owner of NV Energy, once said that, “Energy deregulation will be the largest transfer of wealth in history.”5 That was before he said owning utilities isn’t “a way to get rich, it’s a way to stay rich.”6 And while energy choice is most accurately referred to as restructuring (deregulation implies the absence of regulation), is it any wonder why NV Energy is spending $30 million to protect their monopoly?

Lower power bills, more renewable energy and more jobs. All will come to Nevada upon passage of the Energy Choice Initiative in November, otherwise known as Question 3.

Question 3 is a constitutional measure that very simply does two things. First, it bans the electric generation monopoly in Nevada and second, it requires the legislature to provide for an open, competitive electricity market by July 1, 2023.

Competition simply lowers prices, even in energy markets. According to data from the Energy Information Administration, the 14 energy choice jurisdictions in which almost one-third of Americans live saw prices fall 14 percent between 2008 and 2015 while monopoly states’ prices rose 5 percent in that same time frame.7 A study presented before the Governor’s Committee on Energy Choice found Nevada ratepayers would see a net benefit of more than $1.1 billion by 2023.8 That equates to savings of $11.16 a month on bills before competitive pricing is even included.

The chairman of the Illinois Commerce Commission estimates that consumers in energy choice states have saved $324 billion dollars on their power bills from 2008 to 2017 as a result of competition.9 According to a 2016 study from Cleveland State University, energy choice saved consumers in Ohio an average of $3 billion per year, for a total of $15 billion over five years.10 In Pennsylvania, according to a study from the University of Pennsylvania, energy competition saved residential customers $818 million in 2016 alone.11 Warren Buffett was right: energy competition is a huge transfer of wealth from the monopoly to us.

Having the option to choose your energy provider means choosing the type of plan that works best for you. Want 100 percent renewable energy? There will be plans available for that, just as there are in other jurisdictions around the country. According to a study from the University of Pennsylvania, renewable energy plans were ‘the most widely offered innovative product’ available to residential customers following energy restructuring ‘by far’.12

At its core, the Energy Choice Initiative is about unleashing Nevada’s renewable energy potential. Consumers will drive the new market and because consumers are demanding renewable energy, that will spur the demand for building those projects right here in Nevada. Consider the data center provider Switch, one of the primary backers of Question 3 and a company who has already exited NV Energy. They have announced they are building 1,000 megawatts of solar energy at a 50 percent discount than what you would have to pay NV Energy to get 100 percent renewable energy today. Other major companies like MGM, Wynn and Caesars have also left NV Energy and have announced solar projects of their own to power their businesses at major savings over the current monopoly utility. Bill Ellard, the chair of economics for the American Solar Energy Society, said, “The utilities are not negative on solar, they are negative on you controlling your own electricity.”

A study done by Nevada-based economist John Restrepo found that because of the demand for building more renewables, Nevada could see an increase of up to 34,080 new clean energy jobs by 2033 as a result of passing Question 3, more than doubling Nevada’s current job total in that sector.13

In November, vote Yes on Question 3 for lower bills, more renewable energy and more jobs.

Sources

  1. Are Consumers Benefiting from Competition?: An Analysis of the Individual Residential Electric Supply Market in Massachusetts by Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office, March 2018; Electricity Prices Expected to Skyrocket this Summer by L.M. Sixel, Houston Chronicle, June 11, 2018; Regulators Blast Electricity Providers for Deception by L.M. Sixel, Houston Chronicle, June 28, 2018; Regulators Seek Default Pricing on Monthly Utility Bills by Jeffrey Tomich, E & E News, Illinois, July 5, 2018
  2. Energy Choice Initiative Final Report by Public Utilities Commission of Nevada, April 2018
  3. Clean Energy Advocates Oppose Nevada Ballot Question 3, Sierra Club Press Release, July 26, 2018
  4. Restructuring the Electricity Market in Nevada?: Possibilities, Prospects and Pitfalls by the Guinn Center, 2018
  5.  “AZQuotes.com”, Accessed 7/27/2018
  6. Who Owns the Sun? by Noah Buhayar, Bloomberg Businessweek, January 28, 2016
  7. Electricity Customer Choice Outperforms Traditional Monopoly by Wayne Kuipers and Laura Chappelle, UtilityDive.com, August 23, 2016
  8. Conflicting Reports Underline Tough Path for Preparing for Energy Choice Ballot Question by Riley Snyder, Nevada Independent, May 10, 2018
  9. Coalition Fights for Energy Choice in Florida by Alex Crees, Choose Energy, January 12, 2018
  10. Electricity Choice in Ohio: How Competition has Outperformed Traditional Monopoly Regulation, Cleveland State University, November 2016
  11. A Case Study of Electric Competition Results in Pennsylvania, University of Pennsylvania, October 28, 2016
  12.  A Case Study of Electric Competition Results in Pennsylvania, University of Pennsylvania, October 28, 2016
  13.  Job Analysis & Forecast: Yes on Question 3 by RCG Economics, October 2016

Filed Under: Crossfire Tagged With: Coalition to Defeat Question 3, Las Vegas business, Nevada business, Reno business, Yes on Question 3

Tonya Ruby: Cox Media Las Vegas

Sponsored Features

Sponsored Features

Sun City Anthem HOACashes in on Water Savings

U.S. Bank’s Good TruckComes to Las Vegas

GC Garcia, Inc. Celebrates 25 YearsAnd Looks Back on Southern Nevada’s Changing Landscape

Las Vegas Valley Water DistrictSupports Local Fire-Fighting Efforts

Advertise With Us

Advertise With Us. more details ►

Primary Sidebar

Business Survival VS. Pandemic DestructionBankruptcy in Nevada

Industry FocusCommercial Brokers

Multi-Family in NevadaLet’s Get Vertical

Then & Now: HendersonEnterprises, Environment and Economics Make Henderson a Great Place to Call Home

Nevada News & PR Wire

  • First-of-its-kind Suicide Prevention Center Opens in Reno

  • Energy & Emissions Tracking Startup, Ledger8760 Appoints Adam Kramer as CEO

  • G.C. Garcia, Inc. Promotes Melissa Eure to President

  • The Abbi Agency Named Agency of Record for Silver State Health Insurance Exchange/Nevada Health Link

  • Reno Marketer & Entrepreneur Leads Biz Assembly Webinar

  • Tuscan Highlands Holds Month-Long Pet Supply Drive in Honor of National Pet Day on Sunday, April 11

  • Northcap Commercial Arranges Sale of Waikiki Palms Apartments for $1,950,000

  • Cure 4 The Kids Foundation Ranks No. 4 Among Best Nonprofits to Work For – National award shines spotlight on Nevada for quality health care

  • Nevada Donor Network Celebrates National Donate Life Month with ‘Hope Glows’ Virtual Fun Run/Walk and Community Partner Donation Drives

  • Southwest Medical Adds Seven New Health Care Providers

  • Las Vegas-Based Developer Welcomes New Residential Neighborhood to Utah

  • Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Nevada Properties Announces Record-Breaking Year

  • Greater Nevada Credit Union Renews Virtual Financial Education Program for Youth

  • WGU Launches ‘Essential Workers Scholarship’ in Appreciation of the Dedication Shown During Pandemic

  • Trosper Public Relations Adds Seasoned Journalist & Master Storyteller to Team

  • Google Donates 100 Hotspot Devices to Students in Need at the University of Nevada, Reno

  • McQuillen, Ridge, Robertson Re-Elected to NCET Board

  • CSN to Hold In-Person Commencement Ceremony May 15

  • RSAR Releases March 2021 Existing Home Sales Report

  • De Castroverde Law Group Partners With Findlay Subaru of Las Vegas to Award $10,000 College Scholarship to a Local High School Senior

  • Raiders Fullback Alec Ingold Partners with Junior Achievement of Southern Nevada for Financial Literacy — Alec Ingold’s Virtual Money Mini Camp for 8th-12th Grade Students —

  • NAIOP Southern Nevada presents April 15 virtual breakfast on how the industrial sector has led the way in Southern Nevada development

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Announces Addition of New Board Members

  • SR Construction Named the General Contractor for the Alper Airport Retail Center Project

  • Southern Nevada Home Prices Keep Springing Forward Amid Tight Supply

  • Joshua Ford Is Recognized as NACD Directorship Certified – Certified Board Members Demonstrate Their Commitment to Elevating Board Leadership

  • Colliers Las Vegas Exclusively Represents Las Vegas Strip Landmark Location for Retail and Introduces New Brand and New Plans

  • Request for Official Naming of Six Open Space Properties in Carson City

  • Substrata Says Pandemic Changed Process but Hasn’t Halted Hiring

  • Donor Network West Lights the Reno Arch Blue and Green for National Donate Life Month

  • SR Construction Receives Two Spotlight Awards from NAIOP Southern Nevada

  • In Plain Sight Marketing launches Small Business Marketing Survey

  • Nathan Adelson Hospice Hosts ‘Empowering Equity in End-of-Life Care,’ a Virtual Multicultural Symposium

  • America First Credit Union and Shaheen Beauchamp Builders Team Up for Successful Project

  • Ainsworth Game Technology Announces Completion of Debt Restructuring Plan with U.S.-based Bank

  • Cleaning up Claim Denials – SB269 to Be Heard April 2

  • Colliers Las Vegas Recognized as Brokers of the Year in Retail and Office During Industry Award Ceremony

  • Southern Nevada’s Newest $32M Industrial Park in Southwest Las Vegas Represented by Colliers’ Willmore Industrial Team

  • Jewish Nevada Announces New Board Members

  • Historic Reno Building Opens as Reimagined Gathering Place, Collaborative Workspace

  • Multipure International Announces Sponsorship of USA Karate Athlete Trinity Allen

  • Code Ninjas® Summerlin and Centennial Hills Announce Summer Camps

  • Siena Italian Trattoria Offers Delectable Delights for Easter Brunch and Dinner

  • Doherty Industrial Group Completes Multi-Million Dollar Sale of North Las Vegas Class a Industrial Property

  • Southwest Medical Adds Two New Health Care Providers

  • Clark County, SNHD & Community Partners Launch ‘Back to Life’ COVID-19 Vaccine Awareness Campaign

  • VGK Foundation to Commit a Total $250,000 as Part of Five-Year Commitment of $50,000 Per Year to Support the Nevada Donor Network Foundation’s ‘End the Wait’ Campaign

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Hosts Air War College International Students

  • NAIOP Southern Nevada Chapter Announces Winners of 24th Annual Spotlight Awards, Presented Virtually

  • JING Las Vegas to Launch Vibe Dining Sunday Brunch Series

  • Plumas Bancorp Relocates Corporate Headquarters to Reno, Nevada

  • Colliers Las Vegas Brokers Dan Doherty, Paul Sweetland, Jerry Doty and Chris Lane Ranked in Sior’s Top 50 Industrial Transactions List of 2020

  • Reno+Sparks Chamber of Commerce Now Offering Association Health Plans Through Prominence Health Plan

  • Chief Justice Hardesty Appoints Judge Marquis and Judge Walker as Co-Chairs of Guardianship Commission

  • Lage Design Announces Addition of Two Landscape Designers

  • New $1.1 million Flight Academy classroom planned at Faith Lutheran Middle School & High School

  • Dunkin’ Joy in Childhood Foundation Helps Bring the Joy of Summer Camp to Kids Battling Illness with $500,000 in Grants

  • Hillel of Northern Nevada Integrates with Jewish Nevada to Continue Expanding Outreach in Northern Nevada

  • Nevada State College Professor Receives National Achievement Award for Innovations in Teacher Education

  • Las Vegas’ Newest Pediatric Skilled Nursing Facility Finalizes Patient Transfer Agreements With Several Valley Hospitals

  • Helix Electric Names Vice President of Operations

  • Dunkin’ Launches Three New Girl Scout Cookie™ Inspired Bottled Iced Coffees

  • Brewery Arts Center Receives Grant for a New Video Wall

  • Miltson Consulting Develops First Phase of $20 Million Mountain West Industrial Park

  • Cure 4 The Kids Foundation Recently Announced Jennifer Buitrago, Chief Nursing Officer – Founding Board Member and Original Clinic Staff Member Elevated to Top Nursing Position

  • Dunkin’ Las Vegas Shows its Appreciation to Local RTC Employees on Transit Worker Appreciation Day

  • From Wednesday to “Wednes-YAY”: Dunkin’ Launches Free Donut Wednesdays

  • Northcap Commercial Arranges Sale of Destino Villas Apartments for $2,976,000

  • Mountain View Lutheran School Holds Hygiene Drive to Benefit Olive Crest as Part of Child Abuse Prevention Month Initiatives

  • The Sperling Kronberg Mack Holocaust Resource Center to open at Temple Beth Sholom on Holocaust Remembrance Day

  • Business Continuity Technologist Finalist in 2021 Nevada Business Awards

  • Helix Electric Honored with Diversity Excellence Award By Associated Builders and Contractors

  • SR Construction Receives Recognition from Associated Builders and Contractors

  • WGU Again Named a Top Ten Military Friendly® School

  • Dunkin’ Debuts First Stores on the World-Famous Las Vegas Strip, Opening Two Locations at The LINQ Hotel + Experience

  • Nevada Dental Association Backs Bill to Protect Patients, Limit Retroactive Claim Denials

  • Placer County Welcomes Nevada Travelers for Springtime Adventures

  • Not So Random Acts of Kindness: Hashtag holidays inspire nonprofit odyssey

  • Last Patented Gold Mine in Northern Nevada Hits Market

  • KPS3 Hires Jared Barnett as Senior Digital Media Producer

  • KPS3 Hires Monica Strohschein as Search and Digital Media Specialist

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Names New Vice President of Retail

  • Weaver Consulting Group Launches New Company Website

  • Award-Winning 61 MWdc Turquoise Solar Project in Nevada Reaches Commercial Operation

  • Skye Canyon’s Fit Fest 2021 Raises $3,000 For Kline Veterans Fund

  • CALV Hosts May 13 Mixer for Commercial Real Estate Professionals

  • Junior Achievement of Southern Nevada Hosting 2nd Annual Virtual Race for Financial Freedom — Participation Through Outdoor and “Do Good” Activities in April —

  • Southwest Medical Adds New Physician

  • Urology Specialists of Nevada Adds New Health Care Provider

  • CSN Assistance League Team up to Help Students – the Partnership Supports Coyote Cupboards Food Pantries on CSN Campuses

  • Low-Cost Resources for Nevadans During Problem Gambling Awareness Month

  • Colliers Las Vegas Welcomes New Property Manager Amber Mcdaniel

  • Project Based (Housing) Voucher Wait List Will Open March 19, 2021 for Larios Arms II Apartments in Winnemucca

  • Dermody Properties Hires Michelle Roland as Investment Manager

  • Cure 4 The Kids Foundation Officially Opens the Robert and Dorothy Keyser Foundation and Cashman Family Foundation Preventative Healthcare Center

  • Greater Nevada Credit Union Announces Board of Directors at 72nd Annual Meeting

  • Colliers Las Vegas Brokers Nationally Recognized for 2020 Successes

  • Las Vegas Developer Sells and Acquires Multifamily Properties

  • The Art of Innovation Artists’ Exhibit is on Display at Reno Ice

  • Routes of Empowerment Discussion to Spotlight Women Across Multiple Industries



 
Submit Your News & PR | Subscribe
Submit Your News & PR

Business Connection

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Nevada Business Calendar

  • Virtual Race for Financial Freedom
    March 23, 2021 12:00 am

    More details...
  • Virtual Race for Financial Freedom
    March 23, 2021 12:00 am

    More details...
View Full Calendar ►

Nevada Business Directory

Featured Businesses
Find a Nevada-Based Business Submit Your Business Subscribe to the Nevada News & PR Wire

Nevada Industries

Architects & Engineers
Arts & Culture
Banking
Commercial Real Estate
Construction
Credit Unions
Economic Development
Education
Financial Management
Healthcare
Human Resources
Insurance
Law
Manufacturing
Marketing
Media
Mining
Philanthropy
Residential Real Estate
Rural Nevada
Sports
Tax Planning and Accounting
Technology
Telecom
Tourism
Transportation
Utilities

Footer

Subscriptions

  • Print Subscription
  • Mobile App
  • E-mail Subscription

Editorial

  • Features
  • Departments
  • Events

Advertising

  • Advertise
  • Submission Requirements

Connect

  • Contact
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2020, Business Link LLC dba Nevada Business Magazine and Nevada Business Journal. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
Nevada Web Design services by Nevada Central Media using Genesis Framework by StudioPress