• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Nevada Business Magazine

The Decision Maker's Magazine

Subscribe Now!

  • Subscriptions
    • Print
    • Mobile App
    • Email
    • Nevada News & PR Wire
  • Features
    • New This Month
    • View Issues
    • Cover Stories
    • Feature Stories
    • Industry Focus
    • Building Nevada
    • Special Reports
    • Press Release Wire
    • Nevada Industries
  • Departments
    • A Matter of Opinion
    • Around the State
    • Business Indicators
    • Commentary
    • Commercial RE Report
    • Crossfire
    • Expert Advice
    • Face to Face
    • Free Market Watch
    • Inside Politics
    • Power of Attorney
    • Profit & Loss
    • Speaking for Nevada
    • Tech.knowledge.me
    • The Last Word
    • Vital Signs
  • Planning Calendar
  • Advertising
    • Advertising Info
    • Advertising Staff
    • Submission Requirements
    • Online Advertising
  • Events
    • NBM Events
  • About
    • About the Magazine
    • Contact the Staff
  • Connect
    • Business Directory
    • Press Release Wire
    • Business Calendar
    • Submit Listing
    • Post Press Release
    • Add Your Event
    • Sign Up
    • Log In
You are here: Home / Departments / Commentary / North Las Vegas’ Eminent Domain Scheme: Well-Meaning, but Dangerous

North Las Vegas’ Eminent Domain Scheme: Well-Meaning, but Dangerous

August 1, 2013 By Lyle Brennan 2 Comments

North Las Vegas' eminent domain is wrong on so many levels. It violates the Nevada Property Owners’ Bill of Rights.
Lyle Brennan

San Francisco-based Mortgage Resolution Partners (MRP) has been pitching a scheme to get distressed cities to use their right of eminent domain to seize underwater homes and pay MRP to help restructure the mortgages. They tried and failed in several cities before finding a receptive audience in North Las Vegas. Naturally, city officials want to help their constituents, who have been hit hard by the recession and the collapse of the housing market, but the agreement they signed with MRP on June 19 goes against both the U.S. and the Nevada Constitutions, puts the city at risk of losing even more money, and could further damage the local housing market.

Under their plan, MRP would identify homeowners who are underwater yet still current on payments, and whose mortgages were financed by private investors and bundled into mortgage-backed securities. Using its power of eminent domain, the city would forcibly take over the properties and pay the current mortgage holders pennies on the dollar. The city could then re-sell the homes back to their current owners at a price closer to market value, assuming the owners could qualify for a new loan. MRP estimates about 5,000 homes in North Las Vegas would qualify for their plan.

As an example, the city takes over a home with a $300,000 note and pays the original mortgage holder only $150,000. Then MRP finds a buyer for a new note at $190,000. Theoretically, the city would make $40,000 (less fees) and the homeowner’s mortgage is now $190,000 instead of $300,000. But what about the holder of the original note? In effect, the city is using its power of eminent domain to take $150,000 away from that investor. These mortgage-backed securities are owned by everyday citizens who have put their savings into investment funds. Why should they lose their investment in order to benefit the underwater homeowner, the city government and MRP?

This “feel-good” proposal is wrong on so many levels. It violates the Nevada Property Owners’ Bill of Rights, which was incorporated into Article One of the Nevada Constitution and bans the use of eminent domain to transfer property between private owners. The agreement also violates the due process guarantees of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and the equal protection guarantee of the 14th Amendment.

Implementing the plan could be costly and carries a lot of risk. MRP is charging $4,500 for each mortgage, and the city would also be responsible for interest and servicing costs. There’s no guarantee that third parties will purchase the new loans. If 5,000 homes qualify for the plan at $150,000 per mortgage, the city could be on the hook for $750 million. And what happens while the city is holding all these mortgages waiting for new investors to appear? Who collects the mortgage payments and handles delinquencies? Does the city really need another bureaucracy?

Investors who currently hold mortgages could sue the city, which could be responsible for court costs. One North Las Vegas citizen, Gregory Smith, has already filed a federal suit in U.S. District Court, asking the court to declare the plan unconstitutional.

This plan would have repercussions for the entire area by making private lenders unwilling to make loans here. And proposed legislation in Congress (Protecting American Taxpayers and Homeowners Act of 2013) would bar federally backed loans in any county where eminent domain is used for mortgage relief.

The agreement with MRP contains a clause allowing the city to back out of the agreement at any time. When the City Council meets on August 21 it should cancel the contract before it gets in any further trouble. While we feel for the people who are stuck in underwater homes, the first rule of lifesaving is not to let the drowning person pull you under, and this is just what’s likely to happen if North Las Vegas continues with this unconstitutional and dangerous scheme.

By Whose Authority?

For more information on my Commentary and to see some of the backup research, or if you wonder why I take the position I take, go to www.LyleBrennan.com.

Filed Under: Commentary Tagged With: Article One of the Nevada Constitution, Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, Las Vegas housing market, Las Vegas real estate, Las Vegas residential real estate, Mortgage Resolution Partners (MRP), Nevada Constitution, Nevada Property Owners’ Bill of Rights, North Las Vegas, North Las Vegas City Council, Protecting American Taxpayers and Homeowners Act of 2013, U.S. Constitution

Sponsored Features

Sponsored Features

U.S. Bank’s Good TruckComes to Las Vegas

GC Garcia, Inc. Celebrates 25 YearsAnd Looks Back on Southern Nevada’s Changing Landscape

Las Vegas Valley Water DistrictSupports Local Fire-Fighting Efforts

Behind the ScenesWith a U.S. Bank Goals Coach

Advertise With Us

Advertise With Us. more details ►

Primary Sidebar

Daunting ChallengesMedical Education in Nevada

Industry FocusHealthcare

Time & SpaceArchitectural Design Trends

Cyber SecurityKeeping Your Business Safe

Nevada News & PR Wire

  • TSK Architects Names New Managing Principal and Design Principal

  • Greater Commercial Lending Opens Online Applications for New Round of Paycheck Protection Program, Wednesday at Noon

  • StoryBook Homes Announces Treville Court – Its First-Ever All Rental Community of New Homes

  • Reflection Bay Golf Club Expands Team with Ken Wright

  • Holland & Hart Announces Election of New Partners in 2021

  • OPD5 Extends Temporary Office Closure Due to COVID-19

  • Global Recruiting Firm MRC Names New CEO

  • Urology Specialists of Nevada Adds Three New Health Care Providers

  • 2021 Resolutions with M Spa — January Specials for CoolTone by CoolScuplting

  • Elizabeth Pearson Earns Certificate in Principles of Public Relations

  • INOVA Announces Winners and Exhibit in Community Artists’ Campaign

  • Brass Cap Development Closes on Three New Valley Properties

  • Desert Radiology Completes 25 Days of Do-Gooders Virtual Gifting Initiative, Donating to 25 Charities in 25 Days

  • Reno/Sparks Association of REALTORS® Releases December 2020 Existing Home Sales Report

  • Vegas PBS to Host Free Virtual Screening of the Zen Speaker: Breaking the Silence

  • Long-Time Silver State Schools Credit Union Volunteer Leonard Petoske Passes Away

  • Naylor & Braster Recognized in U.S. News Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms” 2021 Edition

  • Goodwill® Among Recipients of $4.2 Billion Funding by MacKenzie Scott

  • St. Jude’s Ranch for Children Begins Healing Center Project for Child Victims of Sex Trafficking with Soil Survey Donated for $1

  • Washoe County Sheriff’s Office and Donor Network West Launch Six-Day “Second Chances” Organ Donation Awareness Program for Minor Traffic Violations

  • Angela Collins Named Chief Operating Officer of Nathan Adelson Hospice; Joins NHPCO’s Quality & Standard Committee

  • NAIOP Southern Nevada Announces Newly Elected 2021 Officers and Directors

  • Immunize Nevada to Host Flu Clinic at Promise Land Community Church

  • Southern Nevada Home Prices End the Year in Record Territory

  • Dickson Commercial Group Represents Buyer of 21,781 Square Foot Medical Office Building

  • Soberlink Joins National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges With Corporate Sponsorship

  • Northern Nevada Community Leaders Named to NCET Board

  • Megan H. Hummel Appointed Partner of Lipson Neilson PC

  • Reno/Sparks Association of REALTORS® Installs 2021 Officers and Celebrates Annual Awards

  • Northcap Commercial Arranges Sale of 11.33 Acres of Land for $5,377,268

  • Nathan Adelson Hospice Partners with Six Leading Non-Profit Providers

  • A Plant-Based Change of Pace: Dunkin’ Starts 2021 with the Southwest Veggie Power Breakfast Sandwich

  • Vegas Helps Nonprofit Organization Launches to Facilitate Locals Helping Locals

  • Deadline for Moving Assistance Applications Extended to Jan. 15, 2021 — Move 4 Less Owners Paying for Local Moves of Families Affected by Pandemic —

  • Livestreamed Panel Discussion Will Engage Local Mental Health Experts, Community Leaders, and the PBS NewsHour Student Reporting Lab on the Topic of Youth Mental Health

  • Silver State Schools Credit Union Shares its 2020 Community Giving

  • Jewish Nevada Announces New Board Members and Presents Jewish Community Leader Awards During Virtual Event in January

  • Ava Rose Agency’s Food and Beverage Clients Raise a Glass to Welcome 2021 With New Year’s Specials and Promotions

  • Throw in the New Year With Dueling Axes at AREA15

  • Take (Extra) Charge of 2021: Dunkin’s New Extra Charged Coffee Delivers 20% More Caffeine

  • Non-Profit CORE Welcomes Two New Members to Board of Trustees

  • Non-Profit CORE Treats 70 Scholars and Families to a Drive-Thru Holiday Express

  • Short-Term Career Training is Key to Post-Pandemic Economic Recovery in Las Vegas in 2021

  • Paint Contractor Gives Children Unforgettable Christmas

  • Greater Nevada Credit Union Helps People Live Greater Through Greater Giving Donations

  • Nevada Association Services Pays First Quarter 2021 HOA Assessments for 5 Families Who Lost Their Homes in November Pinehaven Wildfire

  • “Hope for the Holidays” Presented by Hope for the City Wraps With Immersive Drive-Thru Food Pantry

  • Nevada Rural Housing Authority Receives Two Excellence Awards from the National Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies

  • Dickson Commercial Group Completes 36 Acre Land Sale in North Valleys

  • Las Vegas Real Estate Company Focuses on Neighborhoods & Communities

  • Justice Mark Gibbons to Retire from Nevada Supreme Court

  • Spencer Fane LLP Partner Ayesha Mehdi Named to American Bar Association Health Law Section Vice Chairships

  • Newly Constructed Industrial Complex Sells for $6.8 Million in Southwest Las Vegas

  • TSK Architects Promotes from Within

  • USDA Recognizes Greater Commercial Lending As #1 Business and Industry Lender in Top Commercial Lender Rankings

  • Serving our Kids Foundation Hosted Contactless Food Drive with Sponsors Clark County Medical Society Alliance, Southwest Medical, OptumCare and SOS Radio

  • Attorney Leon F. Mead II Receives Recognition for Legal Excellence for 2020 Super Lawyers® Award

  • Mendy Elliott Named Nevada Donor Network Foundation Founding Board Member

  • John Naylor Represented British Columbia Securities Commission in Landmark Decision From Nevada Supreme Court

  • Young Entrepreneur Spills Insight on Launching a Podcast

  • The Private Bank by Nevada State Bank’s High Net Worth Report Summarizes Charitable Giving Trends Impacted by TCJA

  • Application Is Now Open for the Cannabis Equity and Inclusion Community (CEICNV) NCCRFund Grant Program in Nevada

  • Adam S. Kutner, Injury Attorneys Wins “Best Accident Lawyer” in the Las Vegas Review-Journal’s “Best of Las Vegas” Reader’s Poll

  • An Outpouring of Support for Las Vegas Cyclist Memorial: Lamar Advertising Donates 68 Billboards

  • Lake Las Vegas Named #1 Southern Nevada Master Plan

  • St. Vincent’s Thrift Stores Offer Unique Gifts

  • William V. Craig, M.D. Joins Nathan Adelson Hospice in Pahrump

  • Behavioral Health NV Encourages Families to Find Substance Use Help During the Holidays

  • Project Worth Encourages Problem Gamblers to Seek Change this Holiday Season

  • JB Public Relations – Boutique Public Relations & Social Media Agency Offers Free Initial PR Crisis Communications and Consultations for Small Businesses in Las Vegas During the COVID-19 Pandemic

  • Move 4 Less Owners Provide Moving Help for Families Being Evicted, Affected by the Pandemic — Applications DUE by Dec. 31 —

  • D’Agostino’s Trattoria Offers Holiday Gift Baskets, In-Dining Specials, and Signature Festive Drink to Ring in the Season

  • MGM Resorts Selects TuffSkin Surface Protection for Leadership Program

  • Kelly LeGrow Named Nevada Donor Network Foundation Board Member

  • BRAZEN Architecture Founder Receives AIA Nevada’s First Ever “Citizen Architect” Honor

  • ‘Weekend College’ Launches at CSN – Designed for Busy Students, Programs in Business, IT, Healthcare and More Are Available

  • Faith Lutheran Middle School & High School Breaks Ground New $3.4 million Tennis Complex

  • Goettl Air Conditioning and Plumbing Looking to Hire Call Center Representatives Throughout Las Vegas

  • Trosper Public Relations Adds to Team

  • Clinician Experience Project Recognizes Southwest Medical Physician

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Names New Chief Human Resources Officer

  • Dermody Properties Leases Remaining Space at LogistiCenter℠ at Speedway in North Las Vegas

  • Rita Vaswani Named Nevada Donor Network Foundation Founding Board Member

  • Nevada State Bank Wins “Best Bank” in Las Vegas Review-Journal Poll for Fourth Straight Year

  • Community Support Needed to Help Homeless Youth for the Holidays –Donate Gifts or Host a Drive–

  • SR Construction Makes Donation to St. Jude’s Ranch for Children

  • Colliers Las Vegas Broker Recognized as Broker of the Year by Prestigious Industry Society

  • Fernley Community Foundation Celebrates Progress with Polaris Grant, New Senior Center Opening

  • Vegas PBS Selects Mary Mazur as New President and General Manager

  • Silver State Schools Credit Union Receives Gold Award for “Best Credit Union” with the 2020 Best of Las Vegas Award

  • Blume Kitchen & Cocktails Plans Pop-up Dinner Featuring Chef Lanny Chin Mon., Jan 11

  • Coral Academy Awarded Gold in Four Categories for Best of Las Vegas Awards

  • NAWBO Southern Nevada Awards Henderson Councilwoman Michelle Romero With Corporate & Government Services Award

  • Nevada State College’s Early Childhood Education Center to Open Fall 2021 Within the New $61.8m School of Education Building

  • Justice Mark Gibbons Honored at Virtual Pro Bono Awards Luncheon

  • Foster Youth and Adoption Agency Mountain Circle Family Services, Inc. Celebrates 35 Years With New Name, Same Community Focus

  • Nevada REALTORS® Present Annual Awards, Including Honoring Chris Bishop as Its REALTOR® of the Year

  • Blume Kitchen & Cocktails and the Stove Host Holiday Drive-Through Experience to Distribute Meals and Essentials

  • Reno Experience District’s First Luxury Apartment Building is Now Open

  • Founders of a Boutique Design Firm Spill Insights on Building a Team and a Partnership With Intentional Leadership



 
Submit Your News & PR | Subscribe
Submit Your News & PR

Business Connection

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Nevada Business Calendar

  • Ely Film Festival 2021
    March 12, 2021 12:00 pm

    Location: 501 E Aultman St, Ely, NV 89301, USA

    More details...
  • Ely Film Festival 2021
    March 12, 2021 12:00 pm

    Location: 501 E Aultman St, Ely, NV 89301, USA

    More details...
View Full Calendar ►

Nevada Business Directory

Featured Businesses
Find a Nevada-Based Business Submit Your Business Subscribe to the Nevada News & PR Wire

Nevada Industries

Architects & Engineers
Arts & Culture
Banking
Commercial Real Estate
Construction
Credit Unions
Economic Development
Education
Financial Management
Healthcare
Human Resources
Insurance
Law
Manufacturing
Marketing
Media
Mining
Philanthropy
Residential Real Estate
Rural Nevada
Sports
Tax Planning and Accounting
Technology
Telecom
Tourism
Transportation
Utilities

Footer

Subscriptions

  • Print Subscription
  • Mobile App
  • E-mail Subscription

Editorial

  • Features
  • Departments
  • Events

Advertising

  • Advertise
  • Submission Requirements

Connect

  • Contact
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2020, Business Link LLC dba Nevada Business Magazine and Nevada Business Journal. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
Nevada Web Design services by Nevada Central Media using Genesis Framework by StudioPress