• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Nevada Business Magazine

The Decision Maker's Magazine

Subscribe Now!

  • Subscriptions
    • Print
    • Mobile App
    • Email
    • Nevada News & PR Wire
  • Features
    • New This Month
    • View Issues
    • Cover Stories
    • Feature Stories
    • Industry Focus
    • Building Nevada
    • Special Reports
    • Meet the Decision Maker
    • Press Release Wire
    • Nevada Industries
  • Departments
    • A Matter of Opinion
    • Around the State
    • Business Indicators
    • Commentary
    • Commercial RE Report
    • Crossfire
    • Expert Advice
    • Face to Face
    • Free Market Watch
    • Inside Politics
    • Power of Attorney
    • Profit & Loss
    • Speaking for Nevada
    • Tech.knowledge.me
    • The Last Word
    • Vital Signs
  • Planning Calendar
  • Advertising
    • Advertising Info
    • Advertising Staff
    • Submission Requirements
    • Online Advertising
  • Events
    • NBM Events
  • About
    • About the Magazine
    • Contact the Staff
  • Connect
    • Business Directory
    • Press Release Wire
    • Business Calendar
    • Submit Listing
    • Post Press Release
    • Add Your Event
    • Sign Up
    • Log In
You are here: Home / Departments / Ask the Expert / Deriving Value from Patents: Legal Challenges and Strategies for Handling Them

Deriving Value from Patents: Legal Challenges and Strategies for Handling Them

April 2, 2012 By Robert C. Ryan Leave a Comment

United States patent grants the owner an extraordinary property right. In exchange for the patent’s teaching of how to make and use a patentable invention, the patent grants the patent owner the exclusive right to seek to exclude others from exploiting the invention. Patent owners can use this exclusion right in a variety of ways. In addition to using a patent to exclude others from the market or as defensive armor to fend off patent attacks by others, the patent owner can sell the patent to another, use the patent to engage in business combinations such as mergers, acquisitions, and joint ventures, or license the patent to one or more others in a wide variety of ways.

Patent sales, related business combinations, and licensing can be remarkably lucrative indeed. Considering licensing as but one example, IGT generates hundreds of millions of dollars per year in patent licensing revenue. For decades, IBM – long considered the most prominent licensor in the world – has generated many billions of dollars annually licensing many of its patents.

However, using a patent to drive a patent sale, business combination or license involves a number of risks. Unlike real property boundaries, which are relatively easily described and precise, patented boundaries are difficult to describe with words and complex patent laws rule regarding their use. As a result, the scope of a patent can be subject to dispute as can the validity or enforceability of the patent. Since a court dispute over a patent not only involves unusually complex rules and procedures but also typically places at least a product or service line at risk, the costs of bringing a patent case to trial typically costs each party to the dispute in excess of one million dollars, excluding the cost of an appeal or other proceedings, such as patent reexamination in the Patent and Trademark Office.

This reality can help lead the parties to resolution such as a patent sale, license, or business combination. It also can present serious traps and problems for the patent owner in seeking to accomplish these ends.

Rightly or wrongly, patent law presents substantial and unique challenges when engaging in discussions about patents. Understanding these challenges can be critical in preserving patent rights and achieving the objectives sought by the patent owner.

Often, the patent owner is the one who identifies a potential infringer. The question can then become how to approach the potential infringer to drive a deal involving the patent. The answer is: carefully. Even then there is risk that the patent owner may wind up being dragged into court, and in an unfavorable location, by the infringer.

Under U.S. law, someone accused of wrongdoing often does not have to wait for the accuser to bring the matter to Court. The accused party often can bring a “declaratory judgment action” in the courts and force the accuser to litigate the matter to conclusion. So it is in patent cases. Under the U.S. Declaratory Judgment Act, a Federal Court may grant declaratory relief when there is “a case of actual controversy” regarding patent infringement.

Until recently, well established patent law had created a way for patent owners to discuss patent issues and potential patent business arrangements without subjecting the patent owner to declaratory judgment action by the potential business partner.  The Supreme Court reversed this rule in 2007. At that time, the Supreme Court held that, even if the patent owner has actually granted a license under the patent to the potentially infringing party, the licensee can nevertheless bring a declaratory judgment action against the patent owner if circumstances indicate that a real controversy exists between the parties regarding patent infringement.

Clearly, discussing whether to enter into a business deal regarding a patent with a possible infringer involves substantial risk of being dragged into court by the possible infringer. Worse, this risk also includes the possibility that the declaratory judgment plaintiff can often bring the action in a forum of its choosing.

In litigation, generally the first to file a complaint in court enjoys the advantage of selecting the forum. This advantage can be particularly significant in the context of intellectual property litigation. Patent discussions with a potential infringer can therefore not only result in undesired litigation with the potential infringer but also in an unfavorable litigation forum of the potential infringer’s choosing as the first to file.

There are strategies when seeking to discuss patent transactions while minimizing and possibly eliminating the risk of facing a declaratory judgment action. These strategies can include reaching an agreement between the parties that no party will bring a declaratory judgment action based on business discussions to come and filing an infringement action before negotiations commence.

In any event, when considering discussing a patent with a potential infringer, the patent owner should be aware of the risks and options for proceeding. A strategy should be determined accordingly.

Robert C. Ryan is a partner and patent attorney at Holland & Hart, LLP, based out of its Reno office.

Jerry M. Snyder is an attorney at Holland & Hart, LLP, also based out of its Reno office.

Filed Under: Ask the Expert Tagged With: declaratory judgement action, declaratory judgment action, Federal Court, Holland and Hart LLP, IBM, IGT, inventions, Jerry M. Snyder, Patent and Trademark Office, patent licensing, patents, Reno, Robert C. Ryan, Supreme Court, U.S. Declaratory Judgment Act, United States

Paul Krakovitz: Intermountain Healthcare

Edward Vance: EV&A Architects

Scott Arkills: Silver State Schools Credit Union

Terry Shirey: Nevada State Bank

Online Advertorials

Online Advertorials

SNWA’s Infrastructure InvestmentsHelp Secure Access to Water Supply

Bank of NevadaFunding Will Provide Nevada Students With Financial Literacy Education

Infrastructure InvestmentsAssure Our Community’s Water Future

Roseman’s College of MedicineAddressing the Physician Workforce Shortage

Advertise With Us

Advertise With Us. more details ►

Primary Sidebar

Get important updates from Nevada Business Magazine, directly to your inbox.
Subscribe

Wild at HeartEconomic Development in Rural Nevada

Industry FocusBankers

Residential NevadaMarket Shifts

Southern Nevada CCIMPassing the Torch to the Next Generation of Professionals

Nevada News & PR Wire

  • CAMCO Nevada Promotes Bree McRae to Regional Director of its Portfolio Division

  • CSN Launches Six New Programs

  • Las Vegas Area Home Prices Dip for Second Straight Month

  • Faith Lutheran Begins 2022-23 Academic Year with New Principal

  • Grand Sierra Resort and Casino Honors a Selfless Medical Assistant as the Most Recent “Grand Hero”

  • Downtown Reno Partnership Announces New Marketing Manager and Office Manager

  • Kamer Zucker Abbott Elevates Kaitlin Paxton to Partner

  • KPS3 Hires Chelsea Bosco as Designer

  • Lipson Neilson’s Joseph Garin and Megan Thongkham Named 2022 Mountain States Super Lawyers

  • Open Enrollment for Upcoming Miss Silver State Pageant

  • Move 4 Less Recognizes Dream Home Art Contest Youth Winners with Party and Prizes

  • LumiZen Wellness Debuts Premier CBD Products for People and Pets Alike

  • Celebrate International Coworking Day at The Coop and Test Drive the Coworking Experience for Free!

  • aha! Reports Exceptional Operating Performance for July 2022

  • ioneer Signs Binding Lithium Offtake Agreement with Prime Planet Energy & Solutions

  • The Problem Solver Show to Interview Man Who Discovered Third Body in Lake Mead

  • Aug. 18 NAIOP Southern Nevada Breakfast Presents “The Future of the Las Vegas Strip Is Here”

  • Pilots Revealed for 2022 STIHL National Championship Air Races

  • Preparing for End of Life Workshop

  • Las Vegas Attorney Offers Free Workshop on Protecting Children’s Inheritance and More

  • CVMC Welcomes Lisa McKinney, APRN to Ironwood Primary Care

  • Realtor Nate Strager Releases Weekly Market Update as Part of His Information Campaign

  • Entertainment and Supper Club Summer Schedule at the Stirling Club Continues to Sizzle

  • Community Leader Don Snyder Elected Chairman of the United Way of Southern Nevada Board

  • Lexicon Bank Sponsors Scleroderma Sprint Event, Fueling Efforts For A Cure

  • Optum Care Cancer Care Adds a New Physician

  • Southwest Medical Adds Three New Healthcare Providers

  • International Celebrity Vocal Coach Romeo Johnson Offers Vocal Lessons To Clark County Residents

  • Team From The Problem Solver Show to Sponsor Free Ice Cream and T Shirt Give Away For Kids

  • Las Vegas Orthopedic Surgeon Offers New Treatment For Limb Lengthening

  • TSK Celebrates O’Brien Middle School Redesign Ribbon Cutting in Partnership With Cumming Group

  • Godspeed Capital-backed Huckabee Architects Invests in TSK Architects

  • Dunkin’ Presents $4,000 to Cure 4 The Kids Foundation From Funds Raised on Iced Coffee Day

  • Nevada Bankers Association Announces 2022-23 Board of Directors

  • Annie Wagner of KPS3 Earns Certificate in Principles of Public Relations

  • NAR Tabs Nevada REALTORS®­ Leaders to Serve in National Leadership Roles

  • Kamer Zucker Abbott Attorneys Selected to the 2022 Mountain States Super Lawyers® List

  • Kamer Zucker Abbott’s Next Webinar: Balancing Employee vs. Employer Rights in Divisive Times

  • Henderson Chamber of Commerce Announces 2022 Board of Directors Additions

  • De Castroverde Law Group and Findlay Subaru of Las Vegas Award $10,000 College Scholarship to Allison Hill

  • Karma and Luck Supports Ukraine Through Donation to Doctors Without Borders

  • Support Local Students and Teachers During the Greater Schools Supplies Drive

  • KPS3 Welcomes Lauren Davis to Team

  • Las Vegas-Based Neteffect Named a Top Firm by Clutch

  • Bank of Nevada Welcomes Michael Pizzi as Managing Director of Commercial Banking

  • Following Nevada Osha’s Adoption of Heat Guidelines, There Are Free Resources for Employers to Protect Employees From Heat-Related Illness and Injuries

  • aha! Launches 50% Off End of Summer Super Sale – Book Now!

  • Evolution of Healthcare with RESET IV

  • Mark Wiley Group Announces Buck Hujabre as New President of Commercial Division

  • Jim Seebock Announces Run for Henderson City Council Seat Ward One

  • WestCor Announces New Director of Marketing and Business Development

  • Home At Last™ by Nevada Rural Housing Launches New 4% Advantage Down Payment Assistance Option

  • Tilt-up construction is complete at Mountain West Industrial Park

  • Grow with Google Provides Nevada Small Businesses With Tools to Reach Customers in Changing Economy

  • Facebook Launches New “Feeds” Tab Connecting Users More Than Ever

  • Trosper Public Relations Announces New Hire in Northern Nevada

  • Emerald Island and Rainbow Club Casinos Partner With Local Woman-Owned Spirits Company to Offer ‘Super Premium Well’ Vodka

  • Greater Nevada Mortgage Provides Down Payment Assistance for Eligible First-Time Homebuyers

  • Education Non-Profit CORE Names Jordan Ashley Berkowitz as Development Director

  • ioneer Signs Binding Lithium Offtake Agreement with Ford

  • Two attorneys from De Castroverde Law Group honored as 2022 Mountain States Super Lawyers Rising Stars®

  • Grow With Google Provides Nevada Small Businesses With Tools to Reach Customers in Changing Economy

  • The NCJFCJ Recognizes the Honorable Linda Marie Bell As the 2022 Impact of the Year Recipient at Annual Justice Innovation Awards

  • Broadbent & Associates, Inc. Donates to Local Youth Hockey Team

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Spreads Mid-Year Cheer with Second Annual ‘Christmas in July’ Event

  • CALVPresenting Sept. 21 Educational Symposium for Real Estate Pros Featuring Cyber Security Expert Frank Abagnale of “Catch Me if You Can” Fame

  • Goodwill® of Southern Nevada Promotes from Within

  • STIHL National Championship Air Races Participating in “A Community Thrives” Fundraising Initiative

  • Northcap Commercial Arranges Sale of Mark & Daisy Apartments for $3,800,000

  • MDX Labs Expands Operations to Include Saturdays, in Response to Clark County’s Elevated Level of COVID-19

  • Downtown Reno Partnership Announces Key Performance Indicators for Fiscal Year 2021-2022

  • Meruelo Family Scholarship Awards $12,500 to Children of Grand Sierra Resort Team Members

  • aha! Inaugurates Nonstop Flights From Reno-Tahoe to Santa Rosa

  • Helix Electric Raises Over $24,000 to Benefit Reno Charities

  • 20 Recent CCSD Grads Offered Apprenticeships at Tesla

  • REMSA Health announces promotion of four leaders within the organization

  • TEDx Speaker at NCET Biz Bite Luncheon in Reno

  • The National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges 85th Annual Conference Brings Participants to Northern Nevada From Across the Nation

  • Northcap Commercial Arranges Sale of 239 W. New York Ave Apartments for $1,015,000

  • LVR Announces Newly Elected Officers and Board Members for 2023

  • JA Worldwide Nominated for 2022 Nobel Peace Prize — Junior Achievement of Southern Nevada Celebrates Prestigious Honor —

  • aha! announces additional flying from Ontario, California to Reno-Tahoe for “Burners”

  • Optum Care Anesthesia adds two new health care providers

  • American Bar Association Appoints Lipson Neilson Shareholder Sandra D. Glazier as a Member of the Commission on Law and Aging

  • CALV President Angelina Scarcelli earns NAR leadership appointment

  • Pacific West Injury Law’s Attorney Visits Children At Sunrise Hospital As Mascot Blue Bear

  • SOUL FULL Sundays At The INDUSTRIAL

  • Serial Horse Killer Reward Goes To $10,000

  • Nevada Women’s Fund Receives $100,000 Award from SilverSummit HealthPlan

  • SILVERSUMMIT HEALTHPLAN AND COMPREHENSIVE CANCER CENTERS EXPAND PARTNERSHIP TO IMPROVE MEMBER ACCESS TO CARE

  • Yolanda Carapia of De Castroverde Law Group is awarded Nevada Justice Association Rising Star Award

  • Project 150 benefits from Game Show Boot Camp

  • Sip For Survivors – New SafeNest Coffee

  • The Downtown Vegas Alliance Elects 2022-2023 Officers and Board Members

  • July 21 NAIOP Southern Nevada breakfast presents “The Changing LANDscape: A Discussion on Land in Southern Nevada”

  • Real Estate Expert Nate Strager provides “Hope for Homeownership” With His New Information Campaign Regarding Housing Assistance Programs

  • WestCor CEO Recognized by Construction Financial Management Association

  • Nonprofit Hosting Education Drive to Support Youth Experiencing Homelessness Reach Their Educational Goals

  • FEA Consulting Engineers Welcomes New Team Members

  • Full Tilt Logistics Announces Massive Expansion of Nationwide Shipping, Warehousing and Distribution Business



 
Submit Your News & PR | Subscribe
Submit Your News & PR

Business Connection

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Business Connection Portal

Log In Sign Up

Nevada Business Calendar

  • Kamer Zucker Abbott Webinar on Crossing the Line? Balancing Employee vs. Employer Rights in Divisive Times
    August 18, 2022 10:00 am

    More details...
  • Special Olympics Nevada Bowl for the Gold
    August 20, 2022 11:00 am

    Location: 1301 W Sunset Rd, Henderson, NV 89014, USA

    More details...
View Full Calendar ►

Nevada Business Directory

Featured Businesses
Find a Nevada-Based Business Submit Your Business Subscribe to the Nevada News & PR Wire

Nevada Industries

Architects & Engineers
Arts & Culture
Banking
Commercial Real Estate
Construction
Credit Unions
Economic Development
Education
Financial Management
Healthcare
Human Resources
Insurance
Law
Manufacturing
Marketing
Media
Mining
Philanthropy
Residential Real Estate
Rural Nevada
Sports
Tax Planning and Accounting
Technology
Telecom
Tourism
Transportation
Utilities

Footer

Subscriptions

  • Print Subscription
  • Mobile App
  • E-mail Subscription

Editorial

  • Features
  • Departments
  • Events

Advertising

  • Advertise
  • Submission Requirements

Connect

  • Contact
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2022, Business Link LLC dba Nevada Business Magazine and Nevada Business Journal. Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions
Nevada Web Design services by Nevada Central Media using Genesis Framework by StudioPress

    *Your Name

    *Your Email

    Phone Number

    Company

    *Subject

    *Your Message

      *Your Name

      *Your Email

      Phone Number

      Company

      *Subject

      *Your Message

        *Your Name

        *Your Email

        Phone Number

        Company

        *Subject

        *Your Message

          *Your Name

          *Your Email

          Phone Number

          Company

          *Subject

          *Your Message

            *Your Name

            *Your Email

            Phone Number

            Company

            *Subject

            *Your Message

              *Your Name

              *Your Email

              Phone Number

              Company

              *Subject

              *Your Message

                *Your Name

                *Your Email

                Phone Number

                Company

                *Subject

                *Your Message

                  *Your Name

                  *Your Email

                  Phone Number

                  Company

                  *Subject

                  *Your Message

                    *Your Name

                    *Your Email

                    Phone Number

                    Company

                    *Subject

                    *Your Message